gaminggamedevprogrammingprojectsmatrixdevGameArtleveldesignemulationmakerTop Subs
4
Add topics

Comment preview

[-]pumpkin4(+3|0)

That's a brilliant discussion. I thought I'd not listen to all of it, but I did and think she's developed excellent arguments, even if I don't agree with all of them. She's done very well to locate significant biases in the publishers' market, particularly here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bibliothèque_de_la_Pléiade It's not clear to me however that this was a 'plot to destroy Western Culture' but rather a plot to promote the publishers they wanted to promote, and in many cases referred to them as classics, in the general use of that term. There have been similar trends in Hollywood, music companies, modern art markets, and all other cultural outlets. So it's good to hear her comments on what happened behind the scenes. BUT, I agree with Hilary that Schiffrin, Gide, and many others in Big Publishing have focused on the CONTROL of the market, to push an anti-imperial, anti-Western European, anti-colonial, ant-Greek, anti-Roman, and anti-Christian publishing market, which was also pro-Jewish, pro-Bolshy, pro-late-stage-capitalism, etc.

There were other movements she could have considered. For example, the Protestant and temperance movements were also attempts to push their religious publications. But as she argues, Schiffrin and Gide wanted to replace that stuff.

I think the general term, 'classic' is still applicable to many examples that she may or may not like. For example, these chapters of Auerbach's 'Mimesis':

• Chapter 1: Odysseus' Scar – Homer, The Odyssey (Book 19)

• Chapter 2: The Abjection of Woe – The Old Testament (Genesis, e.g., the sacrifice of Isaac)

• Chapter 3: Fortunata – Petronius, Satyricon

• Chapter 4: The Arrest of Peter Valvomeres – Ammianus Marcellinus (contrasted with Tacitus)

• Chapter 5: Sicharius and Chramnesindus – Gregory of Tours, History of the Franks

• Chapter 6: Roland Against Ganelon – The Song of Roland (Chanson de Roland)

• Chapter 7: The Knight Sets Forth – Chrétien de Troyes, Yvain (The Knight of the Lion)

• Chapter 8: Adam and Eve – The Mystery of Adam (Le Mystère d'Adam)

• Chapter 9: Farinata and Cavalcante – Dante Alighieri, Inferno (Canto 10)

• Chapter 10: Frate Alberto – Giovanni Boccaccio, The Decameron (Day 4, Novella 2)

• Chapter 11: Madame du Chastel – Antoine de la Sale, Little John of Saintré (L'Histoire et plaisante cronique du petit Jehan de Saintré)

• Chapter 12: The World in Pantagruel's Mouth – François Rabelais, Gargantua and Pantagruel

• Chapter 13: L'Humaine Condition – Michel de Montaigne, The Complete Essays

• Chapter 14: The Weary Prince – William Shakespeare (focusing on historical/political drama and the Elizabethan worldview)

• Chapter 15: The Enchanted Dulcinea – Miguel de Cervantes, Don Quixote

• Chapter 16: The Prince of Celli – Molière, The Misanthrope / 17th-century French classicism (Pascal, Racine)

• Chapter 17: The Interrupted Supper – Abbé Prévost, Manon Lescaut

• Chapter 18: In the Hôtel de La Mole – Stendhal, The Red and the Black (Le Rouge et le Noir)

• Chapter 19: Germinal – Émile Zola, Germinal

• Chapter 20: The Brown Stocking – Virginia Woolf, To the Lighthouse

[-]JasonCarswell2(+1|0)

It's not clear to me however that this was a 'plot to destroy Western Culture' but rather a plot to promote the publishers they wanted to promote...

I agree with her - and you.

Sure some were good, or even great, but for decades I bought and read a lot of "classics" without understanding what was even worth reading them for. Now, the Internet can answer some of my questions, but not all. I had a big list of "Books To Get" (and other lists for other media), but would forget why/how things got on that list. The top things were pretty clear, but in a used book store I'd jump at stuff just because it was on my list for a long time.

...which was also pro-Jewish, pro-Bolshy, pro-late-stage-capitalism, etc.

How could that surprise you?

The culture wars attempt to shape ALL of the narratives. All your brains is belong to ZZZusZZZ.

I have not read Auerbach's 'Mimesis', and may have even heard of it, and look forward to learning more.

Perhaps it's worth of being a future focus of the Goat book club? Got your copy of Neal Stephenson's 'Anathem' (2008)? One week to get it - then we start reading the first chapter(s). Maybe I should start now if I'm slow.

[-]pumpkin2(+1|0)

Thanks for this and the Goat book club recommendation. I'll take a look at the weekend.