The Twilight Zone. 26 episodes a season, so done fast. Expensive for television in the 1960s, but nothing compared to what's spent on crap today. And quality, though to be sure there are bad episodes and episodes that just don't work.
Babylon 5. 22 episodes per season, so a typical production schedule for TV at the time, more or less a one week shoot per episode. Cheaper than most TV of the time, let alone SF TV. And excellent, even including the bad episodes that occur a few times each season.
And contrast those with, again, something like The Acolyte that had luxurious amounts of time for production, a budget of north of a quarter billion dollars, and it was utter dogshit.
"Fast - Cheap - Good; pick any two" is a rule of thumb, but not an inviolable law of physics.
I never claimed it was physics - but that logic applies to production of most things. You can always find outliers, but the rule of thumb still applies. Those are rare exceptions.
In those examples, what is not counted is the unmeasured development and time. Critically, absent in many if not most, they had a good premise, good writing, and good pre-production in preparation before even shooting. If it's not magical on the page, it's extremely unlikely to be magic on screen.
I know what you're talking about, and it was summarized very well a little over twenty years ago in Everything Bad Is Good For You, but that's not what Drinker is talking about. The fact that serialized storytelling got very complex and challenging even in "mere action" shows like 24 does not make recent garbage like The Acolyte, She-Hulk, Rings of Power, Wheel of Time, any KurtzmanTrek series, or other message-infused shows "good", no matter how carefully the show-runners try to rationalize it.
And honestly, old TV isn't that painful to watch. Yes, there are "blinking red arrows" that EBIGFY talks about, and other artifacts of the era when TV had to keep everybody up on what was going on in the story, including people who tuned in late, and those who missed things and could not rewind. But if you can get past that, shows like Hill Street Blues, Emergency!, and Magnum, P.I. are superior to anything being made today on a writing level, just not on budgets or "cinematic" look. There were a few shows in the late 2000s that managed to combine the best of all worlds, but they didn't really catch on. The Chicago Code was effing brilliant, and cancelled after half a season (but it managed to tell a complete story).
And Drinker is making a point that former network executive Paul Chato has also made: shows used to live and die by how much audiences liked the characters, and if they liked the characters, bad and average episodes were forgiven. But Hollywood executives disdain "formula" and they all want to be lauded for making the best prestige series, with writing staffs who've never actually learned how to write for television because the pros who could mentor them were fired for being old and white and male.
Agreed. Yes, the old shows like Archie Bunker, Bionic Woman, Charlie's Angels, etc. are not impossible to watch, but the distinctions are bold.
In addition to the seemingly lost art of weaving plot and character arcs with appeal, charisma, and rational comprehensibility, Hollywood has been spread ever so thin across millions of entertainment avenues, rather than a meritocracy with (((nepotism))) focused across a few channels and a handful of studios.
Restating the obvious manufactured compliance... Modern serials are designed to be little more than addictive binge time-sucks. The "complexity" and world-building lore is inconsequential ephemeral voyeurism designed to be addictive investments, trapping and paralyzing folks in their sunken-cost fallacy fantasies that they know everything about but are useless to beneficially utilize. Their copyright-controlled consumer-culture fandom lives rent-free in their brain-rot. Meanwhile Romerica burns around the throngs of zombies.
Like games taking forever. Gta6 . The workers take long on purpose so they have jobs Longer.
You get 66%, at most, of these options - you can have it cheap, fast, quality, but never 100%.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_management_triangle
Counterarguments:
The Twilight Zone. 26 episodes a season, so done fast. Expensive for television in the 1960s, but nothing compared to what's spent on crap today. And quality, though to be sure there are bad episodes and episodes that just don't work.
Babylon 5. 22 episodes per season, so a typical production schedule for TV at the time, more or less a one week shoot per episode. Cheaper than most TV of the time, let alone SF TV. And excellent, even including the bad episodes that occur a few times each season.
And contrast those with, again, something like The Acolyte that had luxurious amounts of time for production, a budget of north of a quarter billion dollars, and it was utter dogshit.
"Fast - Cheap - Good; pick any two" is a rule of thumb, but not an inviolable law of physics.
I never claimed it was physics - but that logic applies to production of most things. You can always find outliers, but the rule of thumb still applies. Those are rare exceptions.
In those examples, what is not counted is the unmeasured development and time. Critically, absent in many if not most, they had a good premise, good writing, and good pre-production in preparation before even shooting. If it's not magical on the page, it's extremely unlikely to be magic on screen.
Modern audiences expect much more.
Watch old movies and television. You'll see.
My own projects are taking way longer than anticipated - and I already anticipated a lot.
The financing, crafting, and post-production all take enormous amounts of time.
I know what you're talking about, and it was summarized very well a little over twenty years ago in Everything Bad Is Good For You, but that's not what Drinker is talking about. The fact that serialized storytelling got very complex and challenging even in "mere action" shows like 24 does not make recent garbage like The Acolyte, She-Hulk, Rings of Power, Wheel of Time, any KurtzmanTrek series, or other message-infused shows "good", no matter how carefully the show-runners try to rationalize it.
And honestly, old TV isn't that painful to watch. Yes, there are "blinking red arrows" that EBIGFY talks about, and other artifacts of the era when TV had to keep everybody up on what was going on in the story, including people who tuned in late, and those who missed things and could not rewind. But if you can get past that, shows like Hill Street Blues, Emergency!, and Magnum, P.I. are superior to anything being made today on a writing level, just not on budgets or "cinematic" look. There were a few shows in the late 2000s that managed to combine the best of all worlds, but they didn't really catch on. The Chicago Code was effing brilliant, and cancelled after half a season (but it managed to tell a complete story).
And Drinker is making a point that former network executive Paul Chato has also made: shows used to live and die by how much audiences liked the characters, and if they liked the characters, bad and average episodes were forgiven. But Hollywood executives disdain "formula" and they all want to be lauded for making the best prestige series, with writing staffs who've never actually learned how to write for television because the pros who could mentor them were fired for being old and white and male.
Agreed. Yes, the old shows like Archie Bunker, Bionic Woman, Charlie's Angels, etc. are not impossible to watch, but the distinctions are bold.
In addition to the seemingly lost art of weaving plot and character arcs with appeal, charisma, and rational comprehensibility, Hollywood has been spread ever so thin across millions of entertainment avenues, rather than a meritocracy with (((nepotism))) focused across a few channels and a handful of studios.
Restating the obvious manufactured compliance... Modern serials are designed to be little more than addictive binge time-sucks. The "complexity" and world-building lore is inconsequential ephemeral voyeurism designed to be addictive investments, trapping and paralyzing folks in their sunken-cost fallacy fantasies that they know everything about but are useless to beneficially utilize. Their copyright-controlled consumer-culture fandom lives rent-free in their brain-rot. Meanwhile Romerica burns around the throngs of zombies.